So, something’s been bothering me about the whole ‘crystal ball’ thing. If Agatha isn’t the second, and she’s not Dovey’s second, then how can she use the crystal? She would have to be related to dovey or sader. So here’s a thought: people are saying that Evelyn sader is Vanessa. And it’s entirely possible. It also explains why Sophie’s blood…[Read more]
Agatha’s always felt like Sader was like a father figure to her, maybe that’s somehow connected? I’m not sure how it would, but maybe. (My brain’s kinda fried from lots of math today, if I come up with more I’ll be sure to share.)
Yeah, I was thinking that too……
I was originally thinking that, but that contradicts the tale of Vanessa and Callis. Something doesn’t line up about this. August sader is the logical thought, but then it makes another thought off. The crystal let Rhian and Japheth know they were there, but if Sophie and Agatha were related to the August, then why would the crystal let Rhian a…[Read more]
Vanessa and Evelyn are probably not the same person, but they maybe sisters or something
When the first book came out and it was the only one out there I kinda had a theory that he was related to Agatha in someway. I know that this might be just because he was a seer but remember how he smiled at her on her first day of school?
wait… that would mean Agatha is related to Tedros
How so?
cos Sophie and Agatha r sisters
How does that relate her to Tedros? Sry my brain is not working lol
i’,m pretty sure it would @shadowmistress5
wierd……..
Yeah but technically not bc they were born with magic Tedros wasn’t
Like Agatha said ‘Family but not family. Blood but not blood. Together but apart.’
I thought Sader named Agatha as his second, even before she came to the school, being a seer and all (and yes I know he couldn’t see how her fairytale ended, but I just assumed it was like this).
That’s an interesting theory. The only thing that doesn’t make sense about that however is possession. It was Dovey’s ball. So wouldn’t she have to make the second?
It’s stated that the seer or the godparent can name a Second, I think.
Sophie and Agatha are technically related to Tedros by blood, but they don’t share the same blood. Sorry if this makes no sense
Wait…how? (I’m sorry my brain is FAILING)
Well actually, if Vanessa is actually Evelyn Sader, the they are technically half siblings with Japeth and Rhian. and Japeth and Rhian are half brothers with Tedros, but by the other parent than with Sophie and Agatha. So therefore Sophie and Agatha have family connected by blood to Tedros, but they they themselves aren’t related. I hope that made sense.
Ah, yes, thanks Alex 🙂
But that doesn’t make sense because apparently Vanessa died in front of Sophie and is in the Brig of Betrayers. And if Evelyn was in Foxwood for a decade then she can’t be in Gavaldon at the same time.
Who knows it might be part of woman’s complicated master plan
I know. It’s super super confusing.
@alexofroom66, that actually makes sense! In book 2, Sader himself said that Evelyn was only his HALF sister. Thus, she might truly be Vanessa’s half sister! We only know a portion of Vanessa and Evelyn’s lives. So who’s to say that’s not entirely possible!
Here is the theory of Vanessa and Evelyn being the same person:
https://www.instagram.com/theblueforest.sge/
If anyone wanted to read it
For whatever reason, I’m almost completely convinced that lady lesso’s backstory will be revealed this time. Also, I wanted to point out a pattern that I noticed with the constant trail of death. So, what we know about it is:
1 whoever is going to die next is likely to have a single chapter.
2 we also know that there’s been a small pattern in at…[Read more]
Who else has a name starting with C? Callis
didn’t she already die? But maybe we get Callis back somehow. Not like back from the dead but in a vision or like how Arthur was able to talk to Tedros at the end of book 5. Agatha would be able to talk to Callis and some major plot point would be revealed that way.
Yes, she died in book 3 (I was pointing out another point in the patter), and while I’d LOVE to see Callis again, I don’t think she’ll come back. A lot of her backstory was already explored in TLEA.
Ah . . . but I do feel as tho we aren’t finished with Callis. I have no idea why tho
But she already is dead
WHOA.
Those were some amazing ideas. C…C…Castor?????
Thank you! And maybe Castor? It might have some chapter where Pollux and castor realize they need each other again, but I don’t know.
The first chapter is actually from the covens POV, so an said he didn’t want to spoil it. But I don’t think you missed anything. Good detective vibes!
Thank you for pointing that out! I didn’t realize. I was kind of expecting it to be Agatha’s chapter again, because she’s had the first chapter in all of the ‘Camelot years’ books.
hmm. at least Soman revealed that Sophie wouldn’t be “mind-controlled” the entire book, so she’ll gain a conscience some time along the way. i liked the things you pointed out here, also!
Thanks! I think Sophie might be ‘mind controlled’ for a longer time then we suspect.
Maybe half way? I know that near the end of the book however, there’s a chapter with a somewhat romantic sounding name? I forget what it is, but I do want to know if it has anything to do with one of our ships.
My name starts with C…
Same. Maybe some of the C characters will be brought back though?
Good theory but all the characters before the 4th book who died didn’t have the letter C at the beginning of their names, but still!
Also the coven starts with C…
And from the information I’ve gained on here, the coven has the first chapter… (also, thanks for the correction. The only character who has died with a C name was Callis, unless I missed someone else.)
Chaddick died too… I be sad
OMG! If the Coven dies, I will cry
If the Coven dies, I will literally cry, even when I finish the book.
If the coven dies I will do something very bad…
WOW
Those are great ideas, and they’ve given me loads more to think about! I hope we find out more about Lady Lesso too, maybe if Japeth brings back Aric from the dead we’ll find out?
Thanks! I think (a personal theory) that Japheth will bring Aric back, and Aric will bring lesso back? I have no clue why, either Aric wants to kill her again or wants something, but I hope that he brings her back to forgive her. I also would like to think Aric’s father will be of some significance.
well maybe this time it might be something that starts with C bc Soman likes to put twists
You know, (not on topic of the post), but, i think Merlin and Prof. Dovey go wayyyyyy back and maybe were bf and gf ? maybe? It seems like they look out for each other. So when Merlin (If hes not dead) finds out that Dovey is dead, he will be very sad and overwhelmed. Idk just a theory!
I think that someone already said this but I thought about it and agree!
I think Merlin is like, wayyyyy older than Dovey though. Think she mentioned him mentoring her at one point? IDK
No I think that Dovey was like either in school with him or taght him. I think it mentions it in the book. She tells her story in the last chapter that shes alive in. :,'(
Note: this isn’t a theory or anything, just a question.
Does anyone else think the likelihood of the one true king’s publication being delayed due to the panic over the new pandemic?
Also: in quests for glory, the lady of the lake had her gates broken into by Japheth right? But the gates open for the king and Merlin. And the lady thought tha…[Read more]
Hmm, I dunno… Also for the publication thing, maybe, I think he’s already finished writing
Idk about the publication thing. I don’t think he’ll delay for the people that preordered bc its coming though mail
Like amazon
Yes, I think it will be delayed in the UK (where I am). Not sure about America though.
Ohh srry yeah prob in the USA (where i am) there will mayybe be a delay in UK
That’s unfortunate. From what I understand though, if you can’t get a physical copy, it would be possible to get the book online, or you could probably order it.
He probably broke in to like prove he was Arthur’s heir or something?
I REALLY HOPE ITS NOT DELAYED!! I CANT’ WAIT!
It’s not delayed. Relax! I watch EverNerverTV, and he would have said something by now
I also watch EverNeverTV. It might not be delayed, but we don’t know. YouTube is demonetizing any videos containing content on the topic of the virus (except videos backed up by information). because it’s a kids channel, they likely wouldn’t have posted about it anyway. I don’t think that means we have to worry though. As much as EverNev…[Read more]
Okay it’s 1:00am and I’ve just been staring at the wall thinking . And then I realized something. Agatha and Sophie are sisters right? And the one true king is siblings with someone. And the bond between them is Sophie (person A) so what if the one true king is Sophie or Agatha, and the bond between them is Tedros? I know there’s already a “ Sop…[Read more]
ok but are you british
um why?
..why?
Um, why?
interesting… maybe…
Yeah the Sophie Agatha sister thing is weird it’s like not brought up at all in any book after TLEA
Okay so i posted something like this a while ago , but it got buried . So in Clarissa’s letter to the Evers (in the handbook ) it says something about the nevers looking for your weakness like snakes in sand . And on the new cover , Japheth and Tedros are in the sand fighting . So here’s what I’m thinking. What if Japheth AND Tedros are the snake…[Read more]
Ooomg that’s so smart!
wow……
Thats a really interesting thought…I hope it isn’t true though.
Honestly , if it was true , there would be so much upheaval that Soman would probably change the entire part of that . So I highly doubt it would actually happen.
Oh wow! It’s a really interesting concept…. but I’m how it would play out if it was real.
I was re-reading crystal in time last night and chapter 18. I just realized a few things that I think would be interesting to get some input on .
1: we still don’t know why Rhian wants the pen’s powers . ( Rhian wanted it to bring back his mother , but there was probably a more simple way , instead of being the one true king and running the ris…[Read more]
Oh my gosh, I like your theory about the pen becoming human and the otk! It reminds of a rly random (and very stange) theory I had a literally about 2 am in which lionsmane and the storian become people and are brothers and the one true king(s)
I thought we figured out who the One True King is. It’s Anadil’s rat on Merlin’s hat on Reaper’s mat
Of course, the rat with the hat and the mat on which they sat 😉
Ah , if only Soman agreed with our wisdom
that’s-
super beautiful
Okay , I just realized something . In the handbook ,(if you read it ) part of dovey’s letter to the first year Evers describe the nevers looking for their weakness like snakes in sand. And here’s the thing ; Japheth doesn’t know what Tedros’ true weakness is . He may have beat him , but that’s because he had Rhian . His spy on the inside wh…[Read more]
Ooooooh
(also when i read spy on the inside i immediately thought of Hamilton the musical *we have a spy on the inside, that’s right, HERCULES MULLIGANNN* lol)
For the Hamilton thing : I was actually thinking about that when I wrote this . (Huge Hamilton fan here, anyone else?)
Ooooh your so right!!!
OHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH MY GOSH THIS MAKES SENSE AND NOW I KNOW WHAT WILL DEFINITELY HAPPEN
@ICEANGEL , nothing in the future is set in stone . But it’s still fun to make random theory’s on it !
Honestly , I really just want to see Aric bring back Lady Lesso. You can see that she cared about him, and it would be interesting to see them reconcile . Any thoughts?
Hm, this could be interesting! I’d be surprised if Aric brought back Lady Lesso, but maybe Agatha/Tedros/and co. will bring her back as their secret weapon against Aric
Honestly, I don’t think that it would ever happen. Aric tried REALLY hard to kill Lady Lesso, and I don’t think that he would want to bring her back.
i really want to see that too! I was thinking, maybe if Lady Lesso and Aric met again and kind of made up, Aric might not be as evil since most of his evil came from the trauma of being abandoned in the woods alone when he was only six.
That’s the reason I want them to reconcile. Aric never knew why lesso abandoned him did he? Perhaps he’ll start to wonder why and ask Japheth to bring her back . But if Tedros , Agatha and those guys wanted to get rid of Aric by reversing Japheth ‘s wish , lesso would have to go too.
Okay, so I just realized something and am freaking out. So in Sophie’s last chapter (in book 5 ) Rhian says that the ‘one true king’ is to marry Sophie to keep their place . So does that mean that ………………… Sophie X Tedros happens ?! Cause then , we’ll i’mma re write this whole series for my own entertainment.
Oh yeah!
I really dont want that to happen, I think Tedros and Agatha is way better.
Btw does anyone else really want Aric to come back from the dead?
No I don’t want Aric to come back since he killed Tristan/Yara and Lady Lesso. And he’d only raise Japeth’s evilness further, if you know what I mean.
Claraofnutcracker402 I love your user name!
@TAGATHAFOREVER16 thank you! I love the nutcracker so I figured i’d use it as my username!
Do you dance?
Yes actually . And I do ballet. That’s partly where I got the Idea from . Because there’s a nutcracker ballet.
I do ballet too! Are you in the nutcracker this year?
@tagathaforever16 , I am in the nutcracker this year, but I’m playing the sugarplum fairy . Are you ?
Yes. I actually just switched ballet schools but but I’m just a maid this year because I’m new
Sophie and Tedros kissed one time remember but there was no love between them.
But if you like, you can write a fanfiction on it. There’s a fanfiction grp on this website.
@SOPHIESWAY
this is our little work box. We can set up ideas here, suggestions, and put together our work. I can make a google doc for this if it would be easier to work on, so feel free to let me know.
A few fairytales I think we could use:
-Snow White
– Rumplestilskin
– Hansel and gretle
Anything you want to add?
I think we should do Hansel and Gretel, since there where many mistakes made.
Okay great! Here a a few mistakes good and evil made, and we just have to explain why it was good or evil. (We can choose one or more, it doesn’t really matter.)
Evil things good did:
– their father abandoned them to die, even though he was good
– the children killed the witch; she may be a witch, but she hadn’t attacked them yet, so they had no…[Read more]
Evil things-
The step-mother commanded the father to leave his children to die.
The children where greedy, wanting to eat the house.
The witch wanted to eat Hansel, and making Gretel watch AND HELP cook her brother.
(the children killed the witch because she was a threat, so they defended himself)
Good things-
Gretel saved her brother form the…[Read more]
Looking good so far! I though we were supposed to be doing evil things good did and good things evil did?
Your probably right, I speed read throught the whole thing.
We could compile a list of both and then compare their differences, while putting emphasis (and short explanations) of how good did evil, and evil did good.
No worries! Ill do just that!
Do you want to compile a list of the good things evil did and the evil things good did, or should I do that, and you can do the evil things evil did and the good things evil did? I have the time to do either, and I don’t mind getting either part. Just let me know which part you want to do, and we can combine the lists into neat sections, and tag t…[Read more]